Wednesday 17 July 2013

Book Club 10th July: Traumatic endings, vegetable crisps and one very well behaved dog



We met at Sue’s house, where we were amply fed and watered. Those vegetable crisps were delicious, not quite sure who ate most of them (innocent face).

We discussed I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings  and agreed that it was unbelievable in parts and with so much conflict packed in, it seemed as though everything in the world that could possibly happen to the poor girl did so. As this book only took her to the age of 16, it makes you wonder what happens in the next (SIX) volumes of her autobiography. 

There were mixed reviews for The Girl Who Fell from the Sky. One person was so traumatised by it that she was unable to read anything but chick lit for a while afterwards, poor girl!  We found some parts of the book  unbelievable and unrealistic, and it was said that the heroine  deserved her comeuppance.

Mostly people seemed to like Lady Susan, which is a short book consisting of letters back and forth. One person said when she got to the end she thought her Kindle had broken, as it didn't seem like the end, though sadly it was. Another person (here’s that innocent face again) 
downloaded it to her Kindle weeks ago and promptly mislaid the Kindle, which has yet to turn up.  Lady Susan prompted a discussion about the postal system and the demise of the handwritten letter. Some members remembered when they could post a letter in the morning and it would arrive in the afternoon – though of course only ‘God, the weather and the state of the roads permitting’!

There were positive reviews all round for The Universe versus Alex Woods, except for me, I admit it – I was a quarter of the way in, and a bit bored. After glowing reports from everyone, I decided to finish it and am so glad I did as I thoroughly enjoyed it. It was agreed that it was funny and different, and a really good read.

We chose our next reads (the links click through to Amazon where you can find out about the books) 

1.       The End of Your Life Bookclub by Will Schwalbe
2.       The Horse Boy by Rupert Isaacson

....and for our third book choice we decided to do something different. We thought it would be fun if we all choose a children’s book to read – it might be one from your own childhood you would like to revisit,  or a children’s book past or present that you would like to read.
We said that to keep ourselves accountable we would say in advance which book we would read – so far people have picked Children of the New Forest, Treasure Island and The Family at One End Street. When you have decided which book you are going to read, please come over to the forum and let us know what you have chosen.

The next book club meeting will be on Wednesday 25th September at Margaret’s house. 

Honorary member Zak